Wednesday, February 09, 2011

LEOPOLD QUESTION 2

2. WHAT IS THE SEASONAL ARRANGEMENT OF THE FIRST PORTION OF THE BOOK MEANT TO COMMUNICATE?

24 comments:

Unknown said...

The seasonal arrangement is a nod to the purposes of farmer almanacs in general: they chart out the rhythms of work to be done on the farm in each season and relate that to the constant of astronomy. But what Leopold is charting is not necessarily human behaviors but, in an intricate manner, the behavior patterns of the world around him, usually birds and mammals and bugs. In the month of "July" Leopold describes the morning calling of the guard amongst all of the bird species by the shack. In April he salutes the unacknowledged Draba plant. All of these creative excercises signal to me a certain kind of local knowledge that is a lifetime achievement. So that's just one value we might take away from the almanac: an example of what solid local knowledge looks like. I think the seasonal arrangement also suggests an understanding of time (much like the tree ring descriptions) that is counter to the rhythms of modern human life and that by extension allows us to examine our own life rhythms.
Cass Curl

Michelle McCadden said...

2. The seasonal arrangement allows the reader to experience a whole year with Leopold, which is important because nature is always changing and evolving. The novel begins with a fresh start in January and cycles through an entire year. The reader is shown the amazing patterns that nature repeats every year and how everything has its niche, without humans even realizing. The short stories with specific details of each month contribute to the overall bigger story and appreciation of nature. By drawing attention to the little things that define each month and season, we can see nature as a whole made up of many different but essential parts. Leopold communicates the importance of all the different seasons and what makes each unique by arranging each chapter as the next month in nature’s cycle.

Serenity W. said...

Each month is part of a chain of events in the ecosystem. How the book is structured acknowledges the yearly, seasonal cycle where specific elements are visible at certain times. The arrangement communicates a sense of journey, a journey of discovery back to the land. Throughout the year we are given the opportunity to follow a skunk track, witness a sky dance or listen for an upland plover’s return flight from the Argentine.

Micki Duran said...

Leopold crosses two writing mediums in order to communicate something bigger that is also a literal example of how to implement a land ethic in our daily lives. He takes the traditional almanac structure, but instead of listing weather patterns or information typical of an almanac, Leopold relates stories that are related to that month for him; it reads almost like an ecologically-minded diary. Subsequently, Sand County Almanac could also be thought of as a book of stories, like an anthology, but rearranged into the monthly system. Leopold has mixed the almanac with a book of short stories; I think this is a brilliant way to illustrate taking a more holistic world view on the literature level. The stories seem personal, being narrated in the first person, yet unlike most other novelists, they are centered upon the land.

Estelle H. said...

The seasonal arrangement implies an intrinsic natural order to the processes of the environment. The environment is not limited to the physical marks of nature such as trees and animals, but it encompasses the processes that guide the organisms themselves. Rain, solar energy, river currents, growth rates of plants, etc. are actions that must be acknowledged as vital aspects of nature. For instance, creating controlled environments that mimic natural atmosphere through use of pesticides or genetically altered seeds are ways we disrespect what Leopold calls "the biotic pyramid". Each layer in the pyramid depends on its surrounding layers to supply it with "food and services". By messing with this pyramid, we disrupt the natural processes of nature which inevitably results in "effects more comprehensive than is intended or foreseen".

Unknown said...

The seasonal arrangement of the first portion of the Leopold's Sand County Almanac mirrors traditional almanacs as there is a kind of chronological order so that the reader experiences the entire year with Leopold. Constructed and written like a journal, the first portion begins in January, showing and informing the reader the regular patterns that occur in nature at specific times of the year, such as rain, river currents and plants to look out for at certain times of the year. However, he personalizes the first portion of the book with short stories and anecdotes and in doing so allows the reader to create a connection with the land. In many ways, this technique deviates from traditional almanacs as almanacs often times reads like a timetable of statistical and environmental data devoid of any sense of personal connection and attachment to the land.

Yuri Abramov said...

When I think about the seasonal arrangement of the first part of the book, I think about the yearly cycle of the earth. Since this is an "almanac", many details and facts of Sand County are presented in a way that tells a cyclical story. Certain things only happen at certain times of the year. The woodcocks only do their sky dance starting in April and continuing till June. The plover comes back in May and spends the summer month in Sand County and retreats once again in the fall to warmer locales. So at the surface level, the different events in Sand County, happen at different parts of the year. Maybe something deeper can be seen: the animals and the natural environment have their patterns of behavior and interaction that are unchanging. By telling the story of one year in Sand County, Aldo Leopold is telling the story of every year in Sand County. If one thinks about the land without humans and our ability to rapidly change landscapes, time takes on a different meaning and proceeds at a much slower pace.

Unknown said...

By using seasonal arrangement to structure the first portion of his book, Leopold invites the reader into his world making it less of a detached reading experience and more of an intimate, immersed experience. We revel along with him in April when the unimportant yet elegant Draba flowers bloom and in May when we see the migration of the upland plover from Argentine to his family’s sand farm. By using the seasons as chapters of his book he not only ties the book closer with nature but also allows the reader to witness the changes, processes, and events of Sand County as if experiencing them firsthand.

Christina Tsui said...

The seasonal arrangement refers to the way in which an almanac is arranged. Seasonal changes warrant changes in the way humans interact with the land, with nature. Leopold attempts to convey the importance of working alongside the land under this structure.

Sam J said...

2. The seasonal arrangement of the first part of the book helps to reinforce the underlying notion that the work is an almanac. An almanac is arranged daily to show events and other pertinent information. The months are also meant to tie us into the natural aspect of the work. By going through a cycle of a year we feel like we are passing through a great extent of time, but this period also goes quickly. We experience the different stages that nature cycles through, which repeat constantly barring interference. Thus, we feel as though we age with the book, because of its structure, and are thus more intimately connected to the nature.

Michelle W. said...

The book traveling through the seasons on his farmstead in central Wisconsin, providing a rich and detailed picture of the rhythm of the work done on the farm and life itself. It demonstrates how life is always changing and evolving, and never stays the same. There are similar patterns in each season, but each passing year is unique. By putting it in chronological order, it makes it easier for the readers to follow and witness the changes and processes that occur in nature. With the short stories and anecdotes, we get to listen to his life and help us understand the importance of a land ethic.

Tila Nguyen said...

Aldo Leopold starts off the first portion of the book by stating the seasonal arrangements from January to December. The structure of each month depicts the cycle of life and what we can experience from it. Each season displays the wondrous ambiguous world of nature and its animals. I believe Leopold hopes to show us that we can witness what happens here in the land. But by stating the decline of the variety of animals in February, if we are not careful the seasons will come again more barren than the last.

Debbie said...

The very fact that the first part of the book is organized into months indicates that different things happen in each month that don't happen every other month; there would be no need to distinguish them otherwise. Thanks in part to evolution, nature is delicate but balanced. The processes of nature are rooted in certain things being there as they should. If humans happen to intrude a little too much and throw off that balance, then the phenomena described in this almanac will cease to exist; they will be present only in this alamanac. For instance, the weather now is very unstable, sunny one day, rainy the next, it's very unexpected. This spastic weather is nature indicating that something is off balance. There are seasons for a a reason and they indicate certain changes that the Earth goes through, it's a cycle. What's happening right now with weather is a disrupted cycle. By using seasons to characterize the first part of the book, Leopold wants to capture the fragileness and beauty of nature and let it serve as a warning to further human disruptions.

Cristina Dukovich said...

Most almanacs are separated into seasonal and monthly categories so the author is trying to show that his work is an almanac. To me though, I believe that the separation of the months conveys the idea of change and to welcome that change. Even though we might not enjoy the weather of a certain month we should appreciate the change that we witness in our environment because it contributes to the diversity around us. Change is good and is a natural and necessary part of life. It is the birth and death cycle that continues whether we like it or not. Instead of fighting it we must accept it.

Sui Wang said...

The seasonal arrangement is not only a call back to traditional almanacs, but a way to express how everything changes from moment to moment, month to month. No animal or tree stays the same each month, and by charting these changes by month, we can observe how all the various species change. Season to season, all wildlife goes through cycles, and by charting it this way, we can experience the cycle with Leopold.

Unknown said...

The seasonal arrangement of the first portion of the book reflects the chronological experiences of Leopold, and how the natural world changes with time. Nature is not a static entity, but is constantly changing and reacting in response to the seasons as well as the influence of humans.

Julie Le said...

Leopold's seasonal arrangement allows the reader to follow his observations of the environment and understand the interconnection of the animals, the land,nature, and human involvement. By progressing from month to month the reader is able to conclude that nature is not separate from human activities, but everything is interrelated and affects each other. Leopold reduced killing woodcocks to ensure that "there be no dearth of dancers in the sunset sky" (34). Leopold was able to reduced killing woodcocks because he learned about the bird and niche. Therefore, in order for us to save the environment, we need to learn about the animals and nature like Leopold.

TanyaF said...

The use of the seasons as chapter titles again refers the information rich attributes not only of almanacs, but of a locals, well aquainted with the land and its cycles of change. As the seasons govern various stages and behavior of the world around him, they make for a sound guide to illistrate changes the land undergoes over time, including life and death, growth and harvest, dark and light. This gives the reader a well-rounded idea of the space being described, much more then a shallow and static observation of this place in a snapshot. It also allows to Leopold to demonstrate his deep mastery of local plant life and features of the land, by including species of plants and animals that even the most mindful oberserver would overlook, but a native of the region would be familiarized with. Thus, Leopold is not only describing the space, he is describing its motion, its intricaies, its life.

Rachel Karp said...

In this section of the book, Leopold is trying to communicate the importance of the month-to-month or season-to-season natural events that occur in Sand County. In March, the geese return from their winter haven; in April, the rivers begin to fill up from the winter snow falls, and in May, the plover has come back from his winter in the Argentine. Each of these months, as well as the other nine, each are significant in their own way for they each have separate natural events that occur within their course. Every event is important and furthers along the cycle of the year and the circle of life.

Cynthia B. said...

The almanac is organized like that of a traditional almanac into timelines. This almanac in particular is broken up into seasons and more specifically months. This is contiguous with his theme of nature and how nature is constantly changing. If one learns the ways the seasons changes and how nature accommodates it, this is the first step to learning local knowledge. Although the months will always come and go, our direct impact on the environment can bring less fruitful seasons and affect the variety of life we have in nature today. This can further meld nature and human activity together, because after all they are not that much separated from one another.

Megan Thomas said...

Leopold lays everything out by month and seasons to display the behaviors and patterns of the nature around him. The attention is drawn to small details that demonstrate although the cycle goes so quickly, it is all tied to the natural aspect of work. The seasonal arrangement is also similar to that of a famer’s almanac, which charts work that needs to be done in each season.

Julia Popova said...

Leopold's seasonal arrangement in the first part of the book is supposed to demonstrate how his book is like an almanac. An actual almanac publishes facts about sunrises and sunsets, and phases of the moons and tides. Leopold's version describes in intricate detail what happens specifically with animals and plants in each month of the year. His way of writing is used in order to illustrate how nature can not be simply described. Each month, a variety of changes happens to nature that most people are oblivious too. Through his use of seasonal arrangement, he demonstrates to the readers that they should focus more on the smaller details within nature.

JACKIE HAVNER said...

The seasonal arrangement of the text underscores the idea of it being an almanac. Farmers almanacs used seasons in assessing their information. it also shows the passage of time in acquiring knowledge. The season draws us away from the I and into the idea of eye. We are not just looking into Leopold's world of I, we are looking into the environment around Leopold of 'eye'--which is exemplified partially through the changing seasons. Nature is in control, we are just a part of it.

Unknown said...

The purpose of Leopold's seasonal arrangement is to show the changes that occur in nature. I interpreted this as a form of behavior that nature partakes in that cannot be manipulated by the individuals who are living in the world. Just like an almanac, we are told through Leopold about the seasons, though we are powerless and can only listen to what happens. This shows that while an almanac is created by humans, we do not create what goes in it, but merely record what nature tells us to put in it.